The New York Times has beat us to it, enlisting the help of a Brooklyn, New York brewer who brewed the Ale. The NYT followed up with a positive review.

I look forward to Smitty's improved, all-grain version made with his favorite grain, hops and the sweat and love of ATK.
UPDATE: Over at Streak's Place, our friend is also brewing and bottling the Porter. Too bad we live a half-country away and cannot do a back-to-back taste test.
I *suppose* I can forgive the esteemed gentleman from the Brooklyn Brewing Company, the sage and wonderful Mr. Garretr Oliver, for beating me to an all-grain Honey Ale recipe.
ReplyDeleteI'll do my own conversion. We'll buy some of Garrett's. We'll taste test and compare.
I suspect I know who wins.
I could not tell if his was extract - what was the tell?
ReplyDeleteIt's Garrett Oliver, owner and brewmaster of Brooklyn Brewery. A Big Dog, if you will. He's not using extract.
ReplyDeleteI stand corrected. They used the word "steeping" in the article. That is a nod to steeping specialty grains before adding the extract.
ReplyDeleteAh ha! Who is the Big Dog now?
ReplyDeleteAs far as living half a country away... Fedex and UPS can solve that issue for you!
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis would be the Romney/Ryan ticket's homemade brew:
ReplyDeletehttp://chameleonbrewing.com